But after two months in the White House, President Trump seems unpersuaded. The 45th president appears poised to become the first in well over a century to not have a dog — or any pet, for that matter — in the White House.
There was the fleeting possibility that Patton, a goldendoodle raised by Florida philanthropist Lois Pope, might join the Trump clan. But Pope ultimately decided she couldn’t bear to part with the dog. Just as well, Trump told her, according to the New York Post; his frequent jet-setting between Washington, New York and Florida wouldn’t accommodate a dog.
But his travel schedule might not be the only factor. Trump doesn’t appear to hold the highest regard for man’s best friend. In fact, one of his go-to insults is comparing someone to a dog: Ted Cruz was “choking like a dog.” Marco Rubio was “sweating like a dog.” David Gregory, Bill Maher, Glenn Beck, Chuck Todd, Mark Cuban — all of them, Trump declared in various tweets and speeches, had been or should be fired “like a dog.”
There’s no sign that Trump’s position on dog ownership is likely to change. Asked for comment, the White House said only that there was no announcement to make. But political history offers some compelling reasons he should reconsider:
Laddie Boy hosting the White House Easter egg roll in 1923 while President Warren G. Harding was out of town. (Library of Congress)
1. Dogs generate good press.
This has been true since the presidency of Warren G. Harding in the early 1920s. “Laddie Boy, the Airedale that belonged to Harding, was really the first to become a media sensation,” says Edward Lengel, chief historian at the White House Historical Association. “Harding brought the dog into Cabinet meetings. He made a big deal about the dog having his own Cabinet chair and hosting the Easter egg roll.”
This reflected true affection, Lengel adds, but also a deliberate PR move: “Harding followed Woodrow Wilson, who was perceived as being very stiff and distant. With Laddie Boy, Harding was trying to cultivate a persona of humanness and warmth and approachability.”
And long before Watergate, Richard Nixon’s career got a big boost from a little pup. In a televised 1952 address widely referred to as the “Checkers” speech, Nixon — then running for vice president on Dwight Eisenhower’s ticket — denied allegations that he had used campaign contributions to cover personal expenses. But he did acknowledge accepting one particular gift:
“It was a little cocker spaniel dog . . . black and white, spotted, and our little girl Tricia, the 6-year-old, named it Checkers,” Nixon said. “And you know, the kids, like all kids, loved the dog, and I just want to say this, right now, that regardless of what they say about it, we are going to keep it.”
It was a pivotal moment. With help from a four-legged friend, Nixon had made himself relatable and sympathetic to the American public. (For a while, at least.)
2. Not having a dog — or not being nice to one — raises suspicions.
Scott Walker’s allergies to dog dander made headlines during his presidential bid, with his spokeswoman having to vow that the Wisconsin governor really and truly liked dogs, even if he couldn’t bear to be near them. Lyndon B. Johnson mostly doted on his dogs, but he alienated some animal-lovers when he famously hoisted his two beagles by their ears for a photo.
And many may recall Seamus Romney, the late Irish setter who received a tidal wave of media coverage during the 2012 race because of the old story of how he got sick while spending 12 hours in a crate strapped to the roof of the Romney family car on a road trip. It spun into a full-blown public debate over canine safety, complete with a protest group calling itself Dogs Against Romney.
(In fairness, not all first dogs are quite so sympathetic. Grover Cleveland’s poodle, Hector, was “famously vicious,” Lengel says. And Sunny Obama was implicated in the reported tackling of a visiting toddler and the alleged biting of one of Malia Obama’s friends.)
President Barack Obama and Bo, his Portuguese water dog, on the South Lawn of the White House in May 2009. (Pete Souza/White House)
3. Dogs bridge political division.
About 44 percent of American households — Democrats, Republicans and everything in between — include a dog. That common ground is powerful, and a first dog gives a president the rare opportunity to be seen, even for a fleeting moment, as just another person who loves a dog.
Consider the photo of Barack Obama, clutching a football in mid-sprint on the White House lawn, with Bo the Portuguese water dog following close behind. Or a snapshot of Ronald and Nancy Reagan joyfully greeting their dog, Rex, after returning to the White House on Marine One: “Their faces just light up,” Lengel says. “In moments like that, you can really see what the dog means to first families.”
And when Bill Clinton’s beloved Lab, Buddy, was killed by a car in 2002, Washington Post political columnist Mary McGrory noted that even the polarizing former president’s “most curdled critics can summon up a little sympathy for him.”
4. Dogs lower stress.
There’s no job more stressful than running the country, and presidents have often turned to their dogs in moments of anxiety or loneliness. Fala, the Scottish terrier beloved by Franklin Roosevelt, helped his master cope with his physical disability, Lengel says. Plus, “FDR was pretty distant from Eleanor,” Lengel says, “so Fala was a real companion there.”
And they comfort others, too. When talk grew tense in Harding’s Cabinet meetings, Laddie Boy brought levity: “Just by his presence, he would reduce the stress level and encourage a sense of working together,” Lengel says.
And then there was Barney, George W. Bush’s Scottish terrier, who starred in a series of Web videos — his 2002 “BarneyCam” debut, offering the public a dog’s-eye look at the White House during the holidays, racked up more than 20 million views. “This was the year after 9/11,” Lengel notes, “and the Barney Cam helped to break down that public sense of terror and fear, and to say that the White House can be a fun place again.”
At the height of the Monica Lewinsky scandal, the Clintons depart for Martha’s Vineyard with their dog Buddy in August 1998. (Robert A. Reeder/The Washington Post)
5. Dogs are loyal.
As the old refrain goes, “If you want a friend in Washington, get a dog.”
Amid the turbulence and controversy of the Vietnam War, Lengel says, Johnson was comforted by his terrier mix, Yuki. In the aftermath of Clinton’s impeachment proceedings, when the family traveled to Martha’s Vineyard, “Buddy, the dog, came along to keep Bill company,” Hillary Clinton wrote in her memoir. “He was the only member of our family who was still willing to.”
Given how often Trump has emphasized the value of loyalty — and his fury with those who betray it — a canine companion might not be a terrible idea.
Bonus: A dog can’t talk to the press.
A previous version of this story mistakenly described Roosevelt’s dog, Fala, as female. Fala was a male.